Rightwing groups around the US are pushing
legislation that would place new limits on what books are allowed in
school libraries in a move that critics decry as censorship often
focused on LGBTQ+ issues or race or imposing conservative social values.
Caught up in the attempts at suppressing books are classics like The Color Purple and Slaughterhouse Five.
Opponents
of such bills argue that they would actually hinder individual rights
because the proponents would be imposing their beliefs on parents and
children who do not share their views. Those campaigning for the
restrictions say it would prevent children from being exposed to what
they label sexually explicit and obscene content and increase parental rights.
There
are at least 112 proposed state bills concerning school – and public –
libraries that seek to expand the definition of what is deemed obscene
or “harmful to minors” and to limit librarian staff’s ability to
determine which books are in their collections, according to the American Library Association.
Judges have already declared some recent laws that banned books unconstitutional and if approved, the other legislation would probably face court challenges.
The
battle over school libraries represents another front in the culture
war over how American society deals with race, sexual orientation and
gender identity.
“Parents want to be able to
have a certain way of making sure that inappropriate, sexually explicit
books aren’t being put in school libraries, and if they ever find these
books in the school library, that they can easily and smoothly remove
those books,” said Mary Elizabeth Castle, director of government
relations for Texas Values, a conservative advocacy group that has tried
to ban books that they describe as pornography and has pushed for creationism to be taught alongside evolution.
While
there have always been efforts to censor books, there has been a surge
in recent years in legislation that concerns material in libraries. In
2014, there were 183 titles targeted for removal from public and school
libraries; in 2023, there were 4,240, according to the American Library Association (ALA), which also states that it is not a complete list.
“There has been a coordinated effort by” groups like Moms for Liberty
that “because of their personal, political, moral or religious beliefs
don’t want young people to be reading certain books, and they want the
publicly-funded schools and publicly funded libraries to reflect their
views”, said Deborah Caldwell-Stone, director of the library
association’s office for intellectual freedom.
In
Texas, there are at least 31 bills – the most of any state – that would
impair libraries ability to “acquire and provide diverse materials,
resources and programming”, according to the library association. During
the 2023-24 school year, there were 538 book bans in Texas, which
trailed only Florida and Iowa, according to PEN America, a group dedicated to promoting free expression.
Texas state lawmakers are now considering senate bill 13,
which would require that local school boards – rather than librarians –
approve all books added or removed from school libraries.
They
would have to establish a local advisory council, comprised mostly of
parents or students in the district, that would recommend which books
should be in the school catalog. And they would not be allowed to have
“indecent” or “profane” content, including books with “grossly offensive
language”.
Christin Bentley, a member of the state Republican executive committee who chairs a subcommittee, stop sexualizing Texas
kids, has advocated for the senate bill because she is concerned about
“sexually explicit [books] and books that tell kids to go look at porn
online”, she said.
“It’s sexually grooming children,” said Bentley, a mother of two who lives near Tyler in the north-eastern part of the state.
Texas
districts have also banned books such as Beloved and The Handmaid’s
Tale, along with newer novels like Extremely Loud and Incredibly Close
and The Underground Railroad, according to the Dallas Observer.
Bentley
said she was most concerned about books like Blue Is the Warmest Color
and A Game of Thrones graphic novel because of their sexually explicit
content.
“A lot of the books that are sexually
explicit or very indecent and profane, they are part of a genre called
young adult, and that’s relatively new,” Bentley said.
While
supporters of such legislation argue that parents need greater control
over what their children are exposed to in schools, librarians already
welcome parent input, according to Lucy Podmore, a librarian and former
chair of the Texas Association of School Librarians.
(Continue)